Dr.King, Misrepresented Quotes, & the Celebration of Death
“I mourn the loss of thousands of precious lives, but I will not rejoice in the death of one, not even an enemy. Returning hate for hate multiplies hate, adding deeper darkness to a night already devoid of stars. Darkness cannot drive out darkness: only light can do that. Hate cannot drive out hate: only love can do that.” –Martin Luther King Jr.
Perhaps you’ve seen the above quote. If not, perhaps you’re familiar with the second half of it. I know I was. Like many of us who understand the complicated sequence of racial oppression within the historical narrative of the United States, you have been graced by the powerful messages evoked by the late Dr. Martin Luther King Jr. However, the above quote is not the words of MLK. Well, not all of them. The latter half of the quote (starting with ‘Returning’) actually finds its roots within Dr. King’s book, Strength to Love. The first half, though eloquent, was written by a woman named Jessica Dovey, who made her statement in a Facebook status to chastise those who were celebrating the death of Osama Bin Laden. She then followed her statement with the latter quote from Dr. King, and the quote quickly became a new sensation, quickly being posted on Twitter and on numerous individuals Facebook pages.
I too added this quote to my Facebook status upon reading it. It was the perfect way of expressing my disdain with the insensitive celebrations following Osama Bin Laden’s death. I could not celebrate his death when there are still millions of marginalized people in the streets of the city that I live in. I could not rally around his death if it would quickly degenerate merely into political points for this nation. I could not cheer, or chant, or praise.
No, instead, I thought about the individuals who experienced the lives of their loved ones taken so abruptly on September 11, 2001, and how his death could perhaps be an epitaph of closure. Instead of celebrating the loss of a human life, I thought about the countless terrorist organizations that are still mobilizing against the land of the “free” (we can discuss the limits of freedom in this country on a different day). These organizations are now more emboldened to martyr their symbol for radical anti-American sentiments. No, I did not celebrate, I reflected on human lives and human dignity.
I understand the magnitude of the situation; therefore I do not wish to deride those who choose to take pride in Osama Bin Laden’s death. But I stand by the aforementioned quote. I stand by Jessica Dovey, who thought to make her voice of compassion heard against the surge of insensitivity. I stand by the sentiments of a great leader who preached that love was the greatest weapon any one could ever hold. And I stand by the thousands of tweeters and Facebookers, who were so eager to share their compassion with the world, that they posted an inaccurate quote.
Very well written editorial style blog, Jonathan. This captures the sentiments of many Americans, especially in my timeline and facebook wall. Would we feel accurately congruent with the sentiments of other nations who rejoiced in the terrorist attack that is now ironically named 9/11? I doubt we would.
There is a blatant lack of humanity in this situation. Logically, there should be amounts of worry and unrest because we should anticipate retaliation from Osama fanatics. Alas, people, including Americans, continue to disappoint, thriving off of animal instincts.
Very well written editorial style blog, Jonathan. This captures the sentiments of many Americans, especially in my timeline and facebook wall. Would we feel accurately congruent with the sentiments of other nations who rejoiced in the terrorist attack that is now ironically named 9/11? I doubt we would.
There is a blatant lack of humanity in this situation. Logically, there should be amounts of worry and unrest because we should anticipate retaliation from Osama fanatics. Alas, people, including Americans, continue to disappoint, thriving off of animal instincts.
Akeem,
Your words reign true. This blatant lack of humanity is the very thing that I worry about. I continue to hope that our capacity to be moral beings outlives our animalistic instincts.
Akeem,
Your words reign true. This blatant lack of humanity is the very thing that I worry about. I continue to hope that our capacity to be moral beings outlives our animalistic instincts.
Hey:
So I think people would react the same way if we had captured him versus his killing. Do you agree?
Hey:
So I think people would react the same way if we had captured him versus his killing. Do you agree?
Well aren’t you special. So high above those of us happy to fight for the safety of our loved ones. Those were some pretty words strewn together in a very intelligent manner but i feel they lack deeper thought on maybe why people are celebrating, not everyone is simply rejoicing in the death of a terrorist. I agree with MLK’s words but this is a situation much different than that of the civil rights movement, and if treated in the same way as the civil rights movement then the land of the free will become the land of the corpses. “A coward dies a hundred times before his death, the valiant die but once.” -Shakespeare’s Julius Caesar.
Well aren’t you special. So high above those of us happy to fight for the safety of our loved ones. Those were some pretty words strewn together in a very intelligent manner but i feel they lack deeper thought on maybe why people are celebrating, not everyone is simply rejoicing in the death of a terrorist. I agree with MLK’s words but this is a situation much different than that of the civil rights movement, and if treated in the same way as the civil rights movement then the land of the free will become the land of the corpses. “A coward dies a hundred times before his death, the valiant die but once.” -Shakespeare’s Julius Caesar.
Livebait:
Respectfully, I don’t believe Jonathan was trying to set himself up on a pedestal. It is completely understandable that those who are celebrating this occurrence are not merely rejoicing in a death, but celebrating an American victory in light of many troubles that have arisen in the past decade. However, I must say that I saw some very ugly comments on people’s Facebooks and Twitter pages that were celebrating an act of war, not a symbolic act of victory and hope. So I think Jonathan’s point is well taken. And I don’t think this blog is a comparison to the civil rights movement at all, rather, MLK is only in the discussion because of the quote that materialized. Yet neverthless, Dr. King’s words are words of peace and love, and those are not constrained to the Civil-Rights Era, but hold true even today.
Livebait:
Respectfully, I don’t believe Jonathan was trying to set himself up on a pedestal. It is completely understandable that those who are celebrating this occurrence are not merely rejoicing in a death, but celebrating an American victory in light of many troubles that have arisen in the past decade. However, I must say that I saw some very ugly comments on people’s Facebooks and Twitter pages that were celebrating an act of war, not a symbolic act of victory and hope. So I think Jonathan’s point is well taken. And I don’t think this blog is a comparison to the civil rights movement at all, rather, MLK is only in the discussion because of the quote that materialized. Yet neverthless, Dr. King’s words are words of peace and love, and those are not constrained to the Civil-Rights Era, but hold true even today.