Stop expecting Black children to grow up straight & cisgender
Loving myself meant refusing to accept the comforts of being respectable.
By George M. Johnson
It was a Sunday night like many others, me sitting at Starbucks finishing up some writing due first thing Monday morning, when a text from my mother came through to our family group chat. It was a picture of me as a young boy, playing Cops and Robbers with my little brother, which seemed to be a severe contrast against my current narrative of “abolish the police.”
I took one look at the picture and instantly started crying. The little boy in the photo had so many protections in place that were no longer needed, and I couldn’t contain the joy for the Queer life I once suppressed but now live.
But my evolution ain’t everybody’s story. Heterosexual conditioning continues to plague the Black LGBTQ community like it did me in my youth, aiding in the devaluation of our lives.
The suppression of my Queer identity was undoubtedly a tool of white supremacy, intent on turning me into a respectable negro—one who could sit at the table, but never have power. Our community is driven towards this respectable goal by systems of oppression, both known and unknown, that force Black children to find their identity through assimilation, not resistance.
Enforcing a heteronormative upbringing onto Queer children is a common practice, but it produces traumatized Black children who carry unhealed wounds and scars into adulthood.
I first realized I was different around 5, as my attractions to other people seemingly deviated from the norm. But my first incident of suppression of my Queerness came in the 2nd grade, when I grew attached to the word “honeychild” and used it to refer to everyone. The school called my parents about it, and my mother sat me down for a conversation.
I was told that I couldn’t use the word anymore, with no explanation given other than “you just can’t.” My mom always served as my first protector, so I knew if she said so it was only to protect me from a world not ready to accept me as I was.
From that moment, I learned how to assimilate into heterosexual culture as a means to protect myself. I liked double-dutch, but also didn’t want to get my ass whooped every day for doing things meant “for girls,” so the 10-year-old me figured out what many go their whole lives unable to. I forced myself into sports, and to be better at them than most.
Covertly I was being called a faggot, while overtly I was one of the first picked to play ball because I had the best jumper on the block. Covertly I was “that gay nigga,” while overtly everyone wanted to be my friend because I could throw shade before niggas knew what shade was, and throw hands if necessary too. I accepted the suppression of my Queer identity as the ultimate trade-off for a future when I would be able to live it freely.
That freedom wouldn’t come until October 23rd, 2014, one week from my 29th birthday, when I wrote my coming out story entitled “Everyone Already Knew I was Gay.” I realized I had been sold a dream, and my entire existence was based on things that would never make me whole. I got to a point where I was tired of living as the person I was pretending to be. I was basing my entire existence on other people’s thoughts of me, so that’s where I started to unpack the problem. I asked myself “who are you, really?” and “what would make you happy?”
Unlearning meant processing trauma, and years of undoing limitations I once placed on myself. I finally reached a point where my happiness could no longer be based on the thoughts and acceptance of others.
I recall sitting down and listing out things I wasn’t doing because I was fearful some would reject me. The simple things were done first. I started bringing men, and gay friends around my straight frat brothers. I started wearing clothes that were much tighter and less masculine as defined by society, because they felt comfortable. The beginning was about coming up from under a shadow that forced me to supress my identity.
I began to use gay lingo even around hetero people, and I stopped cringing when my girl friends would call me “Girl!” This process was as much performative to the world as it was becoming comfortable with who I always knew I truly was. Taking things one step at a time and not fast-forwarding the process allowed me to grow into my identity, and help keep my sanity within the new community I was entering.
The world I thought I knew started to have much more color to it. As I opened myself up to Queer spaces, I inevitably came into contact with more Black folks of different identities, illuminating the range of agency within my Blackness. Unlearning became a natural process initiated by acceptance of things I felt were inherently driving me to resist against the society-enforced principles placed upon me.
Loving myself meant refusing to accept the comforts of being respectable, and knowing that my existence as a Queer person would never be a respectable thing.
The unlearning eventually brought me back to the place where it all started, the little boy in the picture who always knew he different, but was unable to be free.
We assign identities onto children due to learned behaviors passed down through culture. When a child does not fit into that box, our first response is to suppress and condemn. We base nurturing on sexual identity in relation to gender norms. We have “gender reveal” parties, already setting up the hetero pathology of a child before they take their first breath of air. The prayer is always for a child to be healthy, but our hope for this “clean bill of health” is often inclusive of a hetero assumed identity.
Heterosexual conditioning is removing the innocence of the child for the comfort of the parent’s conditional love, and society’s conditional acceptance. A society can only grow when constructs rooted in obedience and conformity are challenged and dismantled, creating environments for people to exist as their whole selves.
A parent’s stance should always be to love the child as they are, nurturing the person they are meant to be. A parent’s job is to protect the person the child actually is, not force the child into the safest acceptable identity. Society cannot advance if we continue to force a binary of gender and sex identity onto a community we refuse to acknowledge. Without this acknowledgement, environments necessary for the safety and sustainability of the Black community cannot be created.
As a community, we must begin to nurture spaces and environments that are conducive to the survival and upbringing of children who are Queer. Society’s attack on the most vulnerable and marginalized is a threat to the liberation of us all. Our jobs are to nurture a Queerness that is already innate, not shape it to a standard of whiteness that none of us can ever be.
George M. Johnson is a Black Queer Journalist and the Managing Editor of BroadwayBlack.com. He writes for EBONY, TheGrio, Teen Vogue, NBC News, Black Youth Project and several other national publications. Follow him on Facebook, Twitter, or Instagram
The suppression of my Queer identity was undoubtedly a tool of white supremacy, intent on turning me into a respectable negro—one who could sit at the table, but never have power.
Lol really? Faks, dites, and transconfusion are trying hard to push for our kids genitals. Sooooo white people oppressed your gay lifestyle. No they enforce it stupid, it’s the black community fighting this madness.
How dare you push this sick death style onto our youth. Look I’ll put it like this, tell me one goodthing yall community has done that’s benefited the black community. Stright Black Pride
#SpeakTruth!!! That just low key pissed me off… “The suppression of my Queer identity”…aint that a bitch.. Seems like Queer folks are trying HARD to make straight people bow down to their queerness, and all of their revised language on gender. FOH… Parents..teach your kids…the “D” goes in the “P”…and correct your BOYS when they hit you up with that girly shit.
Before I get started, let me make myself perfectly clear, I STRONGLY BELIEVE THAT EVERYONE HAS THE RIGHT TO BE AND DO WHATEVER OR WHOMEVER THEY WANT TO BE OR DO, AS LONG AS IT IS LEGAL AND DOESN’T INFRINGE ON THE RIGHTS OF OTHERS, with that being said, to say that not wanting our black men to be gay is some form of white supremacy is illogical and stupid! I’m a proud, straight, 53 year old black man, who has witnessed and been a victim of racism and discrimination as a police officer, a father, and as simply a Black man, and whether you like it or not, fair or not, right or wrong, the reality is this…WHITE AMERIKKKA IS NOT INTIMIDATED BY GAY MEN! Gay men are looked upon as unthreatening and weak,(once again, not saying it’s right or fair, simply the truth.), this country has been and still is intimidated by, and terrified of a strong, proud, morally sound, family oriented, traditional, black man, My personal opinion, I believe it’s the other way around, our young black boys are being emasculated, through bad parenting, deadbeat fathers, a criminal Justice system targeting our young brothers, discrimination in the health and education levels, and most importantly, a culture of music, television, and movies that is creating an immoral, selfish, corrupted enviroment that promotes drug an alcohol abuse, casual sex, material wastes, unrealistic lifestyles, and homosexuality. The Black gay community are too busy pushing the lgbt agenda, most of which cares little about black gays, than the issues of African Americans as a whole, how many in the lgbt community have openly supported Colin Kaepernik? How many for Black Lives matter? And the same Black gays are quick to vilify and insult any black person that, even though they might not agree with your lifestyle, would still support your right for equality! look, I understand and respect your fight for respect and equality, and would be the first to say you deserve it and would support your efforts, just please do me one favor, STOP TRYING TO COMPARE THE STRUGGLES OF BEING GAY TO THAT OF BEING BLACK IN THIS COUNTRY! Whether you feel you were born to be gay or not, whether you felt it was nescessary to do so or not, YOU CHOSE TO COME OUT! Nobody would have known(everyone can assume!), but you, and others like you chose to come out, you can hide being gay, YOU CAN’T HIDE BEING BLACK! I GUARANTEE, you’ve been discriminated more for being black than for being gay!
Black Queer People literally started the Black Lives Matter movement, which–in addition to actually building an activist community on the left among people of color–actually created an infrastructure to monitor and hold police accountable for ways they police our communities and use violence with impunity. This awareness has led to a profound cultural shift among liberals and also provided the necessary infrastructure to confront Trump and other neo-Nazis by the left. But please tell us more about how Black Queer People aren’t actually doing anything for the Black Community when we are its artists, writers, social workers, care givers, and back clappers.
You’re conflating “LGBTQ community” with “white queer community”. And sure, it’s definitely the case that–to my mind–none or very few organizations or non-profits that are, let’s be clear, staffed primarily by white gay men and women have come out in support of Kaepernick. But I would argue that that is because of antiblackness in their very structures–that they can’t because doing so (even if they believed his cause was just) would result in them losing massive numbers of donors, donors who, let’s also be clear are largely white and moneyed. So there are absolutely economic pressures that ensure their silence. But let’s not also pretend that such institutions and systems are categorically loved by the black queer and SGL people who need to take advantage of them due to structural and systemic neglect.
I am somewhat afraid of writing a post in this medium, as I am not a black person, and I understand that this space was not created for me. I am not going to pretend to know what its like to be discriminated for being black, because I don’t know. I am a Mexican queer man who feels greatly indebted to the black community, and I am appalled at your comments.
Let me explain.
Black Lives Matter is a movement that was created by three QUEER BLACK WOMEN. Bayard Rustin, who coordinated the big Civil Rights march in Washington, in which MLK gave his “I have a dream” speech was a GAY BLACK MAN. Marsha P. Johnson was a BLACK TRANS WOMAN who initiated the Stone Wall Riots, and started the modern LGBTQ rights movement. So, you are wrong. LGBTQ people, in particular BLACK LGBTQ people have done a great deal for both the BLACK and the LGBTQ community. And we are all (yes both you as a black man and me as a queer man of color) indebted to them and to their work. The problem here is not “gay” people, but rather, WHITE GAY people, as well as non-black gay people, who refuse to question their place within a white supremacist system. We need to support each other’s struggles because they are and have always been intertwined. The liberation of some of us rests upon the liberation of the rest of us. In the words of Patrisse Cullors “our resistance has always been queer!” As a non-black queer man of color, I am committed to dismantling both the racist system that oppresses you and I, and the homophobic system that oppresses me and other queer people. I invite you to do the same.
I did not know that about the founders of the BLM movement, I also agree completely that there is a distinct difference between the fights for rights and respect for the gay community as a hole, and the gay community of color. We may not agree on lifestyles, but I will vote for and support any and all candidates that fight for equal rights, dignity, and respect for all.