Do Black Men Have a Problem with Short Hair on Women? Heck Yeah
Recently, I’ve decided to chop off 2/3 of my natural hair that I’ve been growing for the last 7 years. Many people are asking, “Why would I do such a thing to such beautiful and lush hair?” And, I say with a resolved grin because I need change and what’s easier than changing one’s hair. Also, I tell them I am tired of feeling in debt to my long nappy tresses. Honestly, with the length of hair I have it takes several hours to wash, detangle, and style. I am devoting too much time to my hair. It’s coming off. I need a manageable length.
For some of my friends and family, this is enough. They say, “Cool, do you sis.”
However, this corner of affirmation seems to be quite limited to the women in my life. For when I have broached this topic with the black men in my life they earnestly urge me to either wait or not to do it all. Initially, I found this puzzling because it ain’t like I’m cutting off my long weave ponytail that sashays behind my derrière which I know some men find erotically appealing. Simply, I am hacking off my puffy nappiness, hair that does not lend itself easily to the male fantasy.
But, it dawned on me in the wee hours of the morning why “many” black men desire long straightened hair and big floppy natural hair because short hair rather it is natural or relaxer girl short makes them uneasy about their hetero-masculinity. You see, long hair, long locks, and big natural hair make women look like what women are supposed to look like. They look feminine. They look motherly. They look like a sexy Pam Grier. They look sweet. They look like a black Barbie doll. And most importantly, they look non-threatening like women. And if a woman looks like a woman, men assume she will act like a woman. This is the politics of embodiment 101.
However, if a woman sports a ball fade, a tiny afro, or a stylish super short cut than it can be assumed that she is a woman who chooses to play by the rules of her own game. Because sporting a ball fade as a woman is a daring act in a hetero-masculine environment. I remember when I first went natural 7 years ago and only had an inch of hair on my head. Men and women alike said with a hint of disgust, “You look like a boy,” and urged me to demarcate my gender by wearing big earrings for they feared I would be labeled a big-ole-black lesbian. And coupled with my black feminist politics they worried about my eternal salvation. Short hair and black feminism is the devil.
Mind you, I am not immune from the inner voices that say, “What if he does not like your short look?” However, I refuse to remain captive by these voices and the voices of men who want me to keep my hair long. I need short hair right now. My life style requires it. I am tired of doing my big hair. As wise women, we must know when things need to end or go underground until the season comes for it to remerge. Meaning, we need to know “for ourselves” when we need to grow or cut our hair rather it is natural or relaxer girl hair.
And, let me put a quick caveat here. My blog is speaking specifically about African-American men who live in the US because I understand hair and gender mean different things around the world.
So, what do you think about short hair on black women? Leave a comment beyond hitting the word “like.”
I think this article is for the most true. However I don’t think all black men feel this way. I think it changes with age,as men and women both begin to focus less on the appearance(though, appearance is important),and more on if the person is a good fit for them. I recently went on a date with a black man to the park. We went to the Museum of Science for about 45 minutes and once we left it was raining outside. He asked me if he wanted me to bring the car around so i don’t get my hair wet and I declined. As we were fast walking back to his car, I said slightly amused, “This is why I miss my weave.”. He chuckled and said to me, ” You know one of the main reasons I was attracted to you was because of your short hair.” As we continued our fast walk back to his car,he to told me why he really appreciated my short hair. He said to me in my younger years(he is 34),which was all the way up until he was 30,he really loved women with long hair weaved or not,but then he started see underlying issues a lot of those women had with self-esteem. I countered with just because women have long or weaved hair doesn’t mean they self-esteem issues,because I would have no problem rocking a weave and then going right back to my short hair. He furthered explained,that isn’t exactly what he meant,but what he was trying to get at was that mens views on women change with age and maturity. He said once he knew that he was ready to have more than just a girlfriend,he stopped focusing on things such as long hair and other outer appearances. He continued on to say,” Don’t get me wrong,I’d still date women that have weaves or long hair,I mean because its just hair. And yes some women look better with longer hair and others with short hair. My thing is this, I’m not trying to date a woman that thinks her looks are all she has going for her nor do I want to be with a woman that don’t understand that your physical appearances can get a man,but it doesn’t keep him.”
I think this article is for the most true. However I don’t think all black men feel this way. I think it changes with age,as men and women both begin to focus less on the appearance(though, appearance is important),and more on if the person is a good fit for them. I recently went on a date with a black man to the park. We went to the Museum of Science for about 45 minutes and once we left it was raining outside. He asked me if he wanted me to bring the car around so i don’t get my hair wet and I declined. As we were fast walking back to his car, I said slightly amused, “This is why I miss my weave.”. He chuckled and said to me, ” You know one of the main reasons I was attracted to you was because of your short hair.” As we continued our fast walk back to his car,he to told me why he really appreciated my short hair. He said to me in my younger years(he is 34),which was all the way up until he was 30,he really loved women with long hair weaved or not,but then he started see underlying issues a lot of those women had with self-esteem. I countered with just because women have long or weaved hair doesn’t mean they self-esteem issues,because I would have no problem rocking a weave and then going right back to my short hair. He furthered explained,that isn’t exactly what he meant,but what he was trying to get at was that mens views on women change with age and maturity. He said once he knew that he was ready to have more than just a girlfriend,he stopped focusing on things such as long hair and other outer appearances. He continued on to say,” Don’t get me wrong,I’d still date women that have weaves or long hair,I mean because its just hair. And yes some women look better with longer hair and others with short hair. My thing is this, I’m not trying to date a woman that thinks her looks are all she has going for her nor do I want to be with a woman that don’t understand that your physical appearances can get a man,but it doesn’t keep him.”
I think it’s sexy and I love wearing my hair short. I recently chopped off my locks (middle of the back-length locks after 5 years)…I got asked: why did you do that? My replies, ‘It ain’t nothing but hair…why do you wear your hair that way?’…Can I be me?
I think it’s sexy and I love wearing my hair short. I recently chopped off my locks (middle of the back-length locks after 5 years)…I got asked: why did you do that? My replies, ‘It ain’t nothing but hair…why do you wear your hair that way?’…Can I be me?
Hi Fallon,
While the specifics are contextually interpreted within racial/ethnic frames, the phenomenon you talk about is also common in white, Hispanic, and Asian gender relation contexts. This is one of those things I’d love to see opinion polled and regressed with standard SES types of controls (hair being the major commecial and social scientific issue it is, I suspect somebody does have such “data” on the topic). My suspicion is that there are significant and relatively large effects within the SES variables.
Liked the piece! BTW, my wife finally shaved her head after years of me saying it would seem to make more sense than the costly (in $$ and time) attempts to control her hair in forms outside its preferred ones. To me, she looked better than everything before, and she still does.
Hi Fallon,
While the specifics are contextually interpreted within racial/ethnic frames, the phenomenon you talk about is also common in white, Hispanic, and Asian gender relation contexts. This is one of those things I’d love to see opinion polled and regressed with standard SES types of controls (hair being the major commecial and social scientific issue it is, I suspect somebody does have such “data” on the topic). My suspicion is that there are significant and relatively large effects within the SES variables.
Liked the piece! BTW, my wife finally shaved her head after years of me saying it would seem to make more sense than the costly (in $$ and time) attempts to control her hair in forms outside its preferred ones. To me, she looked better than everything before, and she still does.
Loved the piece. Please know that I got the same reaction when I cut my hair to about an inch in length 8 years ago. My pastor looked at me like I had joined a cult, lol! So yes, I think short hair on Black women challenges hetero-norms, and speaks to a more basic but complicated truth, which is that for Black folks in the U.S. hair has almost always been political. I think here of the stories of my friends who’ve gone natural and then been approached by guys who think they subscribe to afrocentric schools of thought, hate white people etc, all the while my girls are looking at them scratching their heads. But I also like the distinction you make between the big natural and the short natural. The latter creates unique problems around gender particularly because of what it allegedly signals about sexuality.
But at the end of the day, you said it right. Wise women . . .need to know when things need to end or go underground…Church!
Loved the piece. Please know that I got the same reaction when I cut my hair to about an inch in length 8 years ago. My pastor looked at me like I had joined a cult, lol! So yes, I think short hair on Black women challenges hetero-norms, and speaks to a more basic but complicated truth, which is that for Black folks in the U.S. hair has almost always been political. I think here of the stories of my friends who’ve gone natural and then been approached by guys who think they subscribe to afrocentric schools of thought, hate white people etc, all the while my girls are looking at them scratching their heads. But I also like the distinction you make between the big natural and the short natural. The latter creates unique problems around gender particularly because of what it allegedly signals about sexuality.
But at the end of the day, you said it right. Wise women . . .need to know when things need to end or go underground…Church!
The women in the photos on this page are GORGEOUS, short hair and all!
The women in the photos on this page are GORGEOUS, short hair and all!
Another stab at black men from a black woman.
Men in general are hard wired to be attracted to women with long hair. Long hair is considered to be a feminine trait.
However, there are many women who look great with short hair but don’t know men just because they prefer women with long hair.
Btw, there are other races of women who wear their hair short, not only black women.
There is NOTHING wrong for a man to be attracted to long hair.
Another stab at black men from a black woman.
Men in general are hard wired to be attracted to women with long hair. Long hair is considered to be a feminine trait.
However, there are many women who look great with short hair but don’t know men just because they prefer women with long hair.
Btw, there are other races of women who wear their hair short, not only black women.
There is NOTHING wrong for a man to be attracted to long hair.
Actually, the two woman in the photos look pretty hot + stylish. Especially the second lady, she has such a gorgeous face. And i’m a black man.
Have you ever thought that maybe its just YOU, not your hair?
To be quite frank, I get pretty tired of black woman saying black men don’t like their hair, dark skin color, the way they act, etc etc. Actually its none of that. its YOU!
Actually, the two woman in the photos look pretty hot + stylish. Especially the second lady, she has such a gorgeous face. And i’m a black man.
Have you ever thought that maybe its just YOU, not your hair?
To be quite frank, I get pretty tired of black woman saying black men don’t like their hair, dark skin color, the way they act, etc etc. Actually its none of that. its YOU!
This is a very thoughtful article. I have rocked my short, natural hair since 2008 and before that from ’96-’03. I cannot think of any thing more beautiful. And, I do not feel like a “big-ole lesbian!” In fact, I think this is the most sexiest hair I have had in my lifetime. Thanks for the article.
This is a very thoughtful article. I have rocked my short, natural hair since 2008 and before that from ’96-’03. I cannot think of any thing more beautiful. And, I do not feel like a “big-ole lesbian!” In fact, I think this is the most sexiest hair I have had in my lifetime. Thanks for the article.