The Princess and the Frog, but what about the White Frog's Hunters?
Today the Princess and the Frog opens across the nation. Of course, I’m going to go see the movie, however like most cynics I wrote a blog about the movie before it premiered approximately two months ago to be exact. So, if my argument is proven wrong by actually seeing the film, I will write another blog saying I was wrong. However, I do not think this will be the case. Also, I hope bloggers, writers, teachers, critics, etc. are equally critical of this movie as they were of the movie, Precious.
The original title of the blog was, Mobs, Cracker Barrel, and Hunters . . . Oh, My.
____________________________________________________________
So, what does a frog, a violent racist white man, and non-violent racially complicit white people have in common? Well, they’re all mammals. No, that’s not the answer because a frog is an amphibian. What they have in common is that they all contribute if not directly participate in the abuse of black women. I know at this point, many of you are wondering how so and in particular how the frog figures into the equation. Well, I’m glad you asked young grasshopper. Inspired by summer’s You Gon’ Be All Right: On Maia Campbell and (More on) Tyler Perry, I decided that I too wanted to map connections between dissimilar current events to talk about how they represent normal and normalizing narratives of violence against black women. The stories I want to talk about are the upcoming Disney movie, The Frog and the Princess and the Cracker Barrel Nut. I know for some of you these stories seem inconsequential to each other. However, if you look closer you will see common strands of violence against black women.
So, let’s begin with talking about Disney’s The Frog and the Princess. Of, course there are many critiques to throw against this movie from the emphasis on girls being Princesses to the racist stereotyping of African cosmologies. However, the bone I have to pick with the film today has to do with the “white” hillbilly “frog” hunters pursuing and hoping to eat the first Black Princess, Princess Tiana, who spends the majority of the film as a frog. Of course, I am pretty sure Disney like the rest of Post-Race America is banking on black people being so desirous of a black princess that they will only see the “clueless” and “stupidly innocent” nature of the white frog hunters because how could the hunters know the true “human nature” of princess Tiana. (In my best sarcastic voice) Just like how could Glen Beck and Joe Wilson know that their comments about Barack Obama were racist they were only saying what they felt they didn’t call him the “N” word. And my response to this hogwash is that’s some cow dung. Yep, just in case you did not catch it I said “cow dung” instead of using the four letter expletive.
Even if the white hillbilly frog hunters are impervious to Princess Tiana’s humanity the historical and at times very present nature (i.e. Duke Lacrosse Team gang rape of Black female Dancer) of white male mobs “hunting” black women’s bodies should have signaled an alarm. But, it did not because it’s all too common of a practice to abuse or to imagine abusing black women whether they are human or in “frog” form. If you are skeptical of my claim all one has to do is look at the footage of the Boston Tea Party March on DC, go to a Cracker Barrel, read about what happened to Semenya, or type the phrase “black girl” into any search engine to know black women like other women of color are subjected to the most violent and horrific forms of real and imaginary physical and sexual abuse and often without legal, societal, and communal recourse.
And let’s be honest, Disney is not completely clueless to the historical meaning of white mobs because if they were the white hillbilly frog hunters would be featured in The Frog and the Princess’ movie trailers, but they are not. To know that they are a part of the movie you have to visit The Frog and the Princess’ Facebook Fan Page. There you meet the white hillbilly hunters—Two Fingers, Reggie, and Darnell. And of course, Disney makes sure to mention how “dim witted” the klan clan is as if their dim wittedness and “hunger” for frog legs is suppose to make us feel as if they do not really mean “intentional” harm to Princess Tiana because if they, the klan clan of hunters, knew she was human than they would not harm her. Yeah right. What crack is Disney smoking? It must be that good stuff that Whitney referred to in her interview with Diane Sawyer. Because if we bring into the conversation the historical setting of the movie—French Quarter turn of the century— white supremacy and racism was the law of the land meaning white men could easily rape and kill black women without retribution meaning the seemingly innocent dim witted white hunters in Disney’s film could literally not only eat frog legs, but also devour black women’s flesh through rape.
And of course, we don’t have to look at historical times to see how white men have violent access to black women’s bodies. Just look at what happened to Tashawnea Hill and 7-year old daughter at a Georgia’s Cracker Barrel. Ms. Hill, an African American woman, was beaten by Troy West, a white man, because she asked him politely to watch out when opening the door at Cracker Barrel. At this affront, Troy West started to beat Ms. Hill and call her Black Nigger Bitch. No one intervened to help her and her daughter. Furthermore, Ms. Hill recalled how some of the white patrons grinned in delight as she was beaten senseless. Can you believe that no one helped her? Perhaps, it isn’t difficult not to believe because just a month ago a black woman was beaten by her husband in broad daylight and no one interviewed to help her.
And of course of many of you are saying what does all of this have to do with an animated Disney Film? Well, it has everything to do with it because movies like The Frog and the Princess and Monster’s Ball represent what is normal, acceptable, if not downright desirous behavior toward and of black women. It becomes publicly sanctioned behavior for men irrespective of race to abuse black women. Therefore, Disney’s animation and characterization of the white hunters as dim witted white hillbillies minimizes the intended violence of the hunters, makes their violence normal, and makes their “hunger” a justified reason for killing Princess Tiana. This all too well reminds me of what a white man screamed at the Boston Tea Party March on DC this last Saturday. Holding a sign that read, “We did not bring guns this time,” a middle age white man begins to fuss about how he lost his job and how the government is too big because of black welfare queens. I know all too well how his words and job loss can justify the retrenchment and sidewalk abuse of black women during this recession time.
Lions and tigers and bears Mobs, Cracker Barrels, and Hunters . . . Oh My!
It’s a very beautiful story, and a beautifully animated movie. Watch the trailer on http://trailers-watch.com/ . Also available in HD.
It’s a very beautiful story, and a beautifully animated movie. Watch the trailer on http://trailers-watch.com/ . Also available in HD.
thanks for this, Fallon. i’ll definitely check out the movie. i’m particularly intrigued by the discussion of the “voices” of the characters and how their voices are important for grappling with race: that is, even if Tiana is a frog for the duration of the movie, because she is “voiced” by a black woman, then the movie remains ostensibly about black people…the materiality of the body becomes secondary to the voicing of those animated bodies. i think this links up nicely with what you’ve written here.
thanks for this, Fallon. i’ll definitely check out the movie. i’m particularly intrigued by the discussion of the “voices” of the characters and how their voices are important for grappling with race: that is, even if Tiana is a frog for the duration of the movie, because she is “voiced” by a black woman, then the movie remains ostensibly about black people…the materiality of the body becomes secondary to the voicing of those animated bodies. i think this links up nicely with what you’ve written here.
I was looking around for sound critiques of this movie since my 10 year old told me she wanted to see it. I was unable to locate one that gave anything clear. So we went to see it on opening night. I was very disappointed in this flick. It was dark and disturbing. How long did it take for us to get a black princess? And still Tiana wasn’t a princess until she married the broke prince. All the other princess’s in Disney stock were princess’s by birth, but Tiana only became princess by marriage what is that all about. There aren’t any black princess born? We have to earn, work or marry into royalty. Yep pretty disappointed…
I was looking around for sound critiques of this movie since my 10 year old told me she wanted to see it. I was unable to locate one that gave anything clear. So we went to see it on opening night. I was very disappointed in this flick. It was dark and disturbing. How long did it take for us to get a black princess? And still Tiana wasn’t a princess until she married the broke prince. All the other princess’s in Disney stock were princess’s by birth, but Tiana only became princess by marriage what is that all about. There aren’t any black princess born? We have to earn, work or marry into royalty. Yep pretty disappointed…
I am sorry to inform you, but Disney’s most iconic princess, Cinderella, was not a princess at birth. She was not a princess until she married a rich prince.
This movie is a fairy tail. And a great one. Get over yourselves and enjoy the story.
I am sorry to inform you, but Disney’s most iconic princess, Cinderella, was not a princess at birth. She was not a princess until she married a rich prince.
This movie is a fairy tail. And a great one. Get over yourselves and enjoy the story.
@Ashon,
Thank you. I think you are right.
@Zinia,
Your point is simplistic at best.
@Ashon,
Thank you. I think you are right.
@Zinia,
Your point is simplistic at best.
nice blog! i had a different take on the purpose of the hillbillies since the point of fairy tales is for children to confront their unconscious, in which the fear of racism most likely exists. check out my blog if you’re interested!
http://hearthesiren.wordpress.com/2009/12/23/the-princess-and-the-frog-the-black-fairy-tale-that-apparently-wasnt-politically-correct-enough/
thanks and have a nice holiday!
nice blog! i had a different take on the purpose of the hillbillies since the point of fairy tales is for children to confront their unconscious, in which the fear of racism most likely exists. check out my blog if you’re interested!
http://hearthesiren.wordpress.com/2009/12/23/the-princess-and-the-frog-the-black-fairy-tale-that-apparently-wasnt-politically-correct-enough/
thanks and have a nice holiday!
also i think Zinia makes a good point, both Cinderella and Tiana have to work hard to attain positions of power. Would it be better if Tiana was locked in a tower or stabbed with a needle? Additionally, the princess by birth, Charlotte, is the one who doesn’t have a happy ending. She has lots of money but no husband, which reifies the idea that hard work is important.
also i think Zinia makes a good point, both Cinderella and Tiana have to work hard to attain positions of power. Would it be better if Tiana was locked in a tower or stabbed with a needle? Additionally, the princess by birth, Charlotte, is the one who doesn’t have a happy ending. She has lots of money but no husband, which reifies the idea that hard work is important.
My cousin would be amazed this blog post. We were not too long ago discussing about this. hehe
My cousin would be amazed this blog post. We were not too long ago discussing about this. hehe
“Even if the white hillbilly frog hunters are impervious to Princess Tiana’s humanity the historical and at times very present nature (i.e. Duke Lacrosse Team gang rape of Black female Dancer)”
http://abcnews.go.com/US/LegalCenter/story?id=3028515&page=1
Not sure if you were aware that no rape ever happened. Your article does give a different spin to the movie, and I wondered when the critics would come out. This movie seems to be a little over the top just to get a black princess on the list to help Disney sell more products to a growing market.
“Even if the white hillbilly frog hunters are impervious to Princess Tiana’s humanity the historical and at times very present nature (i.e. Duke Lacrosse Team gang rape of Black female Dancer)”
http://abcnews.go.com/US/LegalCenter/story?id=3028515&page=1
Not sure if you were aware that no rape ever happened. Your article does give a different spin to the movie, and I wondered when the critics would come out. This movie seems to be a little over the top just to get a black princess on the list to help Disney sell more products to a growing market.
another thing: not sure how the remark by Joe Wilson can be construed as racist. You are making assumptions about this movie based on your experiences, Joe Wilson made his comment based on fact. President Obama’s proposal would allow for illegal immigrants to be covered under the healthcare plan. Obama saying that they would not is a lie, and while the decorum of the moment was broken, the lie is still a lie. Calling out that fact is not racist, just factual.
another thing: not sure how the remark by Joe Wilson can be construed as racist. You are making assumptions about this movie based on your experiences, Joe Wilson made his comment based on fact. President Obama’s proposal would allow for illegal immigrants to be covered under the healthcare plan. Obama saying that they would not is a lie, and while the decorum of the moment was broken, the lie is still a lie. Calling out that fact is not racist, just factual.
oh and belle from beauty and the best was not born a princess either
oh and belle from beauty and the best was not born a princess either
I just wanted to correct one thing for Victoria. If you actually pay attention to the Disney princesses you would see that not all of them were “born” princesses. Belle, Mulan, Cinderella, and Snow White were not “born” princesses. They, like Tiana, came from nothing and became something. Also, the whole Duke Rape thing, not sure if you read up on it but the whole thing was a fabricated lie. Maybe you should wait until something is finished before passing judgment. Lastly, the “Racist Frog Hunters,” really? Three characters see two frogs, which are green if you couldn’t tell, decide they want to cook them up, and then get their hind parts beat by said green frogs. If there was any racial message, which there is not, it would be a black woman beating up the “racist” white men. So I think you should consider, and this is just a suggestion, not jumping to racist conclusions at the drop of the hat. Let us not forget that constantly saying things like “white man” this and “white man” that is racist too. As a black man I am sad that this type of thought still exists.
I just wanted to correct one thing for Victoria. If you actually pay attention to the Disney princesses you would see that not all of them were “born” princesses. Belle, Mulan, Cinderella, and Snow White were not “born” princesses. They, like Tiana, came from nothing and became something. Also, the whole Duke Rape thing, not sure if you read up on it but the whole thing was a fabricated lie. Maybe you should wait until something is finished before passing judgment. Lastly, the “Racist Frog Hunters,” really? Three characters see two frogs, which are green if you couldn’t tell, decide they want to cook them up, and then get their hind parts beat by said green frogs. If there was any racial message, which there is not, it would be a black woman beating up the “racist” white men. So I think you should consider, and this is just a suggestion, not jumping to racist conclusions at the drop of the hat. Let us not forget that constantly saying things like “white man” this and “white man” that is racist too. As a black man I am sad that this type of thought still exists.